Chapter 4

The Cut-Out Architecture: InterNASA, TTSA, and Parallel Structures

4. The Cut-Out Architecture: InterNASA, TTSA, and Parallel Structures

4.1 The Cut-Out Concept

A "cut-out" is an intelligence community term for an intermediary that allows two parties to interact without direct contact. In the context of technology assessment, a cut-out allows the government to assess private sector technologies without formal acknowledgment of the assessment relationship. The cut-out structure provides deniability — if the relationship is exposed, the government can credibly state that it had no formal relationship with the technology developer.

Declassified CIA records establish the operational patterns that define a cut-out structure:

  • No written contracts: CIA LILINK (1963) operated with "no written contracts of any kind." Colombia networks operated on the principle that "everything must be agreed to orally."
  • Shell company structures: Blackwater used 30+ shell companies. The Firmage network used 12+ interconnected LLCs.
  • Carve-out oversight suspension: SAP carve-out contracts suspend normal congressional oversight.
  • "License to lie": SAP officials can legally deny a program's existence. Denial of involvement is expected behavior, not evidence of non-involvement.
  • Funding obfuscation: SAP funding is "not directly linked to the program." Approximately $59 million flowed through ManyOne LLC — potentially including pass-through SAP funding.

4.2 InterNASA (2016-2018)

InterNASA was launched in 2016 as "National Academy of Science and Arts, LLC" — a Firmage-connected company. Its characteristics are consistent with a private sector cut-out for technology assessment:

  • Intelligence connections: Ronald Pandolfi (alleged CIA "Weird Desk") and Hal Puthoff provided intelligence community credibility
  • IC methods: The company used "intelligence summaries" and surveillance — intelligence community operational methods
  • Technology focus: Anti-gravity and advanced propulsion technology assessment
  • Personnel: Technical experts providing unpaid voluntary services under 50 USC 3203
  • Corporate structure: 12+ interconnected LLCs (all now expired), consistent with shell company obfuscation
  • Collapse: ~2018 when the project ended — all LLCs began expiring, leaving no public trace

4.3 To The Stars Academy (2017-2021)

TTSA was launched in 2017 — one year after InterNASA — as a public-facing entertainment and science company. Its characteristics are consistent with a public disclosure vehicle for the same network:

  • Intelligence connections: Luis Elizondo (AATIP director), Chris Mellon (former Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Intelligence), Hal Puthoff
  • Public-facing: NYT article (December 16, 2017), media campaigns, entertainment content
  • Technology focus: UAP disclosure and advanced technology acquisition
  • Corporate structure: Public company (delisted 2021)
  • Collapse: Delisted 2021 — the public cut-out was no longer needed

4.4 The Parallel Structure

Likely: Both InterNASA and TTSA were commercial vehicles for the "Invisible College," serving complementary roles in a coordinated strategy:
  • InterNASA was the private/quiet cut-out: Technology assessment, no public profile, unpaid technical experts
  • TTSA was the public/loud cut-out: Disclosure, media campaigns, entertainment content
  • Hal Puthoff was the common link between both entities
  • The one-year stagger (InterNASA 2016, TTSA 2017) suggests a coordinated strategy — first establish the quiet assessment channel, then launch the public disclosure channel
  • Both collapsed when the cut-outs were no longer needed — InterNASA ~2018, TTSA delisted 2021

4.5 The Corporate Structure

The Firmage network's corporate structure — 12+ interconnected LLCs — is itself consistent with intelligence community cut-out methodology:

  • Motion Physics LLC, Motion Sciences, Science Invents LLC
  • ManyOne LLC, ManyOne World LLC, ManyOne Networks Inc., ManyOne Foundation
  • Academy of Sciences and Arts LLC (DBA InterNASA), InterNASA LLC
  • Integral Initiatives LLC, 21C Corporation
  • FPT (separate but connected through Banduric)

Approximately $59 million flowed through ManyOne. The SEC investigated (2016-2017) but took no enforcement action (January 2018). All entities have since expired — no public trace remains, consistent with SAP cut-out design. The corporate structure served its purpose and was dissolved.

4.6 The Personnel Structure

The personnel structure of the cut-out reflects the "Invisible College" network:

  • Technology intermediary: Hal Puthoff — imported Russian gyroscope, CIA/DIA compartmented program veteran (Stargate)
  • IC technology assessor: Ronald Pandolfi — CIA "Weird Desk" (alleged), DNI/DIA technology assessment
  • ODNI DS&T: Dr. David A. Honey — statutory authority for private sector technology assessment (2016-2018)
  • Public-facing entrepreneur: Joe Firmage — corporate face, recruited experts and investors
  • Unpaid technical expert: Participant A — voluntary services under 50 USC 3203
  • Technology developer: Richard Banduric — FPT spin-out, later SBIR transition
  • Media/communications: Bob Kiviat — public narrative management
  • Investor/financier: Ken Marriott — visible private funding

External Primary Sources (3)

Verified external sources (USPTO patents, FOIA releases, peer-reviewed papers, news reports) that corroborate claims in this chapter.